261025- Why Do Many Japanese Learners Struggle to Speak English

26/10/25 @jee54321 1

Key Question Why do many Japanese learners study English for years but still struggle with fluent conversation? This presentation focuses on: Historical background Educational structure Social environment Future changes driven by AI 2

3

Fact 1 English Education Originally Served Knowledge Import During the late 19th century, Japan modernised rapidly. The primary goal was not speaking English. Instead, Japan needed people who could: Read Western books Understand new ideas Translate knowledge into Japanese English functioned mainly as a gateway to science, law, economics and technology. 4

Fact 2 Japan Has a Long Translation Tradition Long before English became important, Japan imported knowledge from abroad through translation. Examples include: Chinese classics Buddhist texts Dutch scientific literature Foreign knowledge was typically adapted into Japanese before being shared nationally. 5

Fact 3 Entrance Exams Rewarded Reading and Grammar For many decades, university entrance examinations focused mainly on: Vocabulary Grammar Reading comprehension These skills were easier to assess fairly across large numbers of students. As a result, learners became skilled at analysing English rather than using it spontaneously. 6

Fact 4 Japan Functions Largely in Japanese Japan possesses: A large domestic economy A large media market Extensive Japanese-language services Most people can: Study Work Shop Access public services without needing English in daily life. 7

Fact 5 Other Asian Economies Often Create Stronger Demand In countries such as: South Korea China English is often linked to: International trade Global business Career advancement Higher salaries The economic incentive to use English can therefore be stronger. 8

Fact 6 AI Is Changing the Value of Translation Machine translation and Generative AI continue to improve. Many translation tasks can now be completed quickly by AI. As a result, the value of language learning may gradually shift from: Translation Communication and collaboration 9

10

Hypothesis 1 The Main Barrier May Be Structural A common assumption is: “ “ Japanese people are not good at languages. This presentation suggests a different possibility: The issue may be related more to the educational structure than to natural ability. People usually become good at what their system rewards. 11

Hypothesis 2 Translation-Based Learning May Limit Fluency Conversation happens in real time. If learners constantly: English → Japanese → English processing becomes slow. Fluent communication usually requires: Direct understanding of meaning rather than continuous translation. 12

Hypothesis 3 Cognitive Linguistics Offers a Different Approach Cognitive Linguistics focuses on concepts and mental images. Instead of memorising translations, learners focus on meaning. Examples: on → contact in → inside at → point The goal is to understand how English speakers conceptualise the world. 13

Hypothesis 4 Taizo Onishi's Grammar Approach Taizo Onishi's method emphasises: Images Meaning Cognitive understanding rather than memorising large lists of rules. The objective is: Understanding English as English instead of converting everything into Japanese. 14

Hypothesis 5 Future English Education May Change Historically: English → Japanese Knowledge Transfer Future direction: English → Direct Understanding → Global Communication This could lead to greater emphasis on: Listening Speaking Interaction Intercultural communication 15

Key Takeaways Facts 1. Japan's English education originated as a tool for knowledge import. 2. Translation has deep historical roots in Japanese culture. 3. Exams traditionally rewarded reading and grammar. 4. Japan can operate largely without English. 5. AI is reducing the importance of translation itself. Hypotheses 1. Speaking difficulties are largely structural. 2. Translation-heavy learning may hinder fluency. 3. Necessity strongly influences language acquisition. 4. Cognitive Linguistics may improve direct understanding. 5. Future education may focus more on communication than translation. 16

Final Thought The challenge may not be that Japanese learners cannot learn English. The deeper question is whether the educational system was designed for a different purpose. As AI reduces the need for translation, future English education may increasingly focus on: Understanding, communication, and global collaboration. 17

18